If there is one subject which makes me squirm it is the debate over asylum seekers. At the core of most discontent, as I understand it, is that hoary old chestnut – are they really asylum seekers or are they illegal immigrants? When I heard this morning that New Zealand had refused entry to a boat of asylum seekers because it would pave the way for ‘millions of others’ and it would ‘reward people smugglers’, I shuddered. I know it's NZ and not Australia this time but still I can’t cope with the discordant feelings the debate elicits in my mind. I'd have preferred to leave my head in the sand and let the Kiwi's debate this one, however, some of the arguments I’ve heard from friends today include -
· Once you accept refugees by boat, people smugglers are rewarded and will continue their callous trade
· Once you accept one boat, others will follow and that put the lives of all aboard in peril (It follows that we would then be complicit in their demise.)
· Once you accept one boat, hundreds will follow and we’ll be inundated – they’ll take our money and they’ll take our jobs
· There should be zero tolerance for illegal immigration and all asylum seekers should use the ‘queue’ and follow set process
· It's legal to seek asylum, even if you arrive on a boat without a visa, and asylum seekers should not be treated as criminals
· Australia is a rich country with plenty to share and we should be more generous in taking responsibility for asylum seekers.
For my part, I think there’s truth in all those statements (though I doubt any jobs are at risk). I hate the thought of people smugglers making money out of these ill-fated people. I hate to think about these unfortunate people, so desperate they would trust their future to a leaky boat. I can’t bear thinking about how many lives have already been lost at sea, how many more will be lost at sea, how many families have been torn asunder. By the same token, I could not bear to face a ‘legal’ asylum applicant and tell them they have slipped further down the queue because they have been usurped by illegal immigrants either. And, even if faced with illegal immigrants, I couldn’t bear to send them back to a place they fear so much that they would risk this horrendous boat trip to escape. And, regardless of any status at all, economic, social or otherwise, I could not face a child and tell them they were not welcome here.
Like everyone else, I have my grizzles about politicians and bureaucrats. Today however, I am so grateful that I am not one of them standing at the front line of the asylum seeker issue and having to make decisions about peoples’ lives. Decisions that polarise populations, devastate families and ruin lives. Today, I send them very genuine wishes for their own health and sanity and thank them for the thankless task they perform. There are some things which are not easily fixed. And now, if you don’t mind, I’ll just pop my head back into the sand and have a little cry.